Silver, Long Form

Silver at $47: What Broke Since $76, and How Sierra Madre Holds Up at Today’s Prices

Silver has lost almost 40% since late May. Here’s what drove it, which parts of the silver story still hold, and what Sierra Madre’s mine looks like when you run its numbers at today’s prices.

November 16, 2026

In late May, silver was trading around $76. The argument for owning silver producers back then was easy to make. Deficits every year since 2021, solar eating up more metal every year, a gold to silver ratio that had come down from over 100 to below 60, and producers making margins that would have looked impossible two years earlier. The $70 to $85 range looked like a floor.

It wasn’t. December silver futures opened at $48.39 this morning and traded down near $47, the lowest open in over a year. Silver is down about 15% in the last month alone and about 38% from that late May level.

When a thesis goes this wrong this fast, the useful thing is to go back through it piece by piece. Some of it broke, some of it is still standing, and some of it was never as strong as it looked. Then I want to do the same for Sierra Madre, because a small producer in the middle of an expansion is exactly the kind of company that feels a move like this the most.

What actually broke

The Fed hiked in September and the market now has over a 90% chance of another hike at the December 8 to 9 meeting. Inflation hasn’t helped. October CPI came in at 0.4% against 0.3% expected, with core at 0.3% for the third month in a row. Gasoline was still rising on top of September’s big jump.

Friday’s PPI was actually a little soft, 0.3% against 0.4% expected, and the odds of a bigger half point hike came down after it. In a different market that might have given silver some room. It didn’t. Silver kept falling into Monday.

That tells you the size of the hike stopped mattering much. What matters now is where the dollar and long term yields are. The dollar index is around 103.4, its highest since April 2025. The 10 year Treasury is near 5.15%. Silver doesn’t pay a yield, so when a risk free 10 year pays over 5%, holding metal costs more. A rising dollar makes silver more expensive for everyone buying in other currencies.

Silver also fell a lot harder than gold, which is normal for silver but still worth showing:

Late MayTodayChange
Silver~$76~$47About -38%
Gold~$4,535~$3,863About -15%
Gold to Silver Ratio~60~82

The ratio is the part that stings for anyone who leaned on it. In May, the argument was that the ratio had come down from over 100 and could keep going toward the 2011 low near 32. Instead it went the other way, back above 80. BMO’s commodity team said last week it expects the ratio to drift to around 85 over the next four years.

What didn’t change, and what changed more quietly

The supply side is still tight, and in some ways it’s tighter.

Q3 production reports from the big Mexican producers were rough. Juanicipio, run by Fresnillo, averaged 330 g/t silver in Q3 against 426 a year earlier. That’s more than a fifth less silver in every tonne. Fresnillo as a whole mined about 10% less silver than a year earlier and pointed to lower grades, with updated models at Saucito confirming narrower veins than expected. Silvercorp’s Ying district in China was down 41% during safety work, and one of its mines could be shut until around November 2027.

That’s real. Miners are getting less out of the ground at the same time the price is falling.

The demand side is where the story changed. Three things stand out.

The deficit is shrinking. The Silver Institute and Metals Focus forecast a 46.3 million ounce deficit for 2026 back in April. Metals Focus has since cut its own estimate to 35.4 million ounces and has a surplus of about 37.3 million ounces penciled in for 2027. The Silver Institute’s interim review is due around now.

Solar went from tailwind to risk. In May, the argument was that solar installations were growing faster than panel makers could cut silver use. BMO now says the opposite. When silver ran above $120 earlier this year, manufacturers had every reason to use less of it or replace it. Matthew Piggott at Metals Focus put it plainly in October: “efficiency gains in panel manufacturing now outpace the growth in solar capacity.” BloombergNEF cut its 2026 solar install forecast to 584 GW, about 11% below 2025.

Investors have been sellers. Funds holding physical silver are down about 60 million ounces this year.

Put those together and the bull case has shifted. It used to be that industry needs more silver than mines can produce. Now it depends a lot more on investors coming back and buying. BMO said as much: investment demand would have to stay exceptionally strong for years to offset what’s happening in solar.

I don’t think that kills the case for silver. Supply still can’t respond quickly, and a 37 million ounce surplus is only about $1.7 billion at today’s price, which isn’t much for the market to absorb if sentiment turns. But it’s a different and weaker case than the one in May, and pretending otherwise doesn’t help anyone.

Why producers fell harder than the metal

The May piece made the case that producers give you leverage to the silver price. That’s true, and it cuts both ways.

A mine has a lot of fixed costs. When silver went from $30 to $76, almost all of the extra revenue fell straight to the margin. When silver goes from $76 to $47, the same thing happens in reverse. Most silver producers have fallen more than silver itself.

Sierra Madre’s stock shows it. The 52 week range is C$1.03 to C$3.25, and with a market cap around C$368 million on about 261 million shares, it was trading near C$1.40 last week.

So the question for Sierra Madre is pretty specific. At $47 silver, does the mine still make money, and can it get its costs down fast enough to matter?

Sierra Madre at $47: the per tonne math

Sierra Madre runs La Guitarra, an underground silver and gold mine in the Temascaltepec district of the State of Mexico. It restarted commercial production in January 2025 and is partway through a two phase mill expansion. In June it closed the purchase of the past producing Del Toro mine in Zacatecas from First Majestic.

The best recent full quarter we have is Q2 2026. Here it is in one place:

Q2 2026
Tonnes Milled41,567
Head grade, Silver65.27 g/t
Head grade, Gold1.05 g/t
Recovery, Silver73.58%
Recovery, Gold67.97%
Silver Produced64,315 oz
Gold Produced945 oz
Realized Silver PriceUS$75.65/oz
Realized Gold PriceUS$4,529/oz
Net RevenueUS$8.23M
Cash Cost Per TonneUS$142.44
Cash Cost Per AgEq OzUS$49.28
AISC per AgEq OzUS$54.73

From those numbers, each tonne milled gave about 1.55 oz of silver and 0.023 oz of gold. That’s my math, not a figure the company reports.

Now price that tonne at Q2 prices and at today’s prices:

Q2 PricesToday
Silver In a Tonne~$117~$73
Gold In a Tonne~$103~$88
Metal Value Per Tonne~$220~$160
After Deductions (~88%)~$195~$142
Cash Cost Per Tonne$142.44$142.44

The 88% comes from Q2 itself. The company booked $8.23 million in net revenue from roughly $9.3 million worth of metal ($5.0 million silver plus $4.3 million gold), so about 88% of the metal value made it through after smelting and other charges.

So on Q2 grades, recoveries and costs, at today’s prices, La Guitarra covers its cash cost per tonne and very little else. Sustaining capital and corporate costs still sit on top of that.

That’s the uncomfortable number, and I think it’s better to look at it directly. But I also don’t think Q2 is the right base for what the mine looks like in Q4 and beyond. Here’s why.

Why Q2 is the wrong base

Throughput. Q2 was a ramp up quarter. Caesars Report put the Q2 average at roughly 450 tonnes a day. The plant hit a steady 720 tpd in September and averaged 751 tpd in October, about 50% above the old 500 tpd nameplate and right in the Phase 1 target range of 750 to 800. A fourth ball mill, rated at 900 tpd, is due to be commissioned this month.

A lot of that $142 a tonne is fixed: the crew, the plant, the camp, overhead. A mill running at 751 tpd doesn’t cost 67% more per day to run than one at 450. So cost per tonne should drop as throughput settles. The company doesn’t split fixed and variable costs, so I can’t put a precise number on it. The direction is clear, though.

Grade and recovery. Q2 grade and recovery were dragged down by development rock from opening up Coloso and Nazareno, and by blending ore from three mining areas at once. Development metres went from 591 in Q2 2025 to 1,188 in Q2 2026. That’s twice the development work, and some of that lower grade rock went through the mill. The company accelerated development and dewatering at the higher grade San Rafael I and II blocks and was targeting first production there by the end of October.

Recovery matters more than people think. Thibaut Lepouttre at Caesars Report estimated that 5% more silver recovery and 10% more gold recovery alone would add about $0.8 million a quarter in pre tax cash flow.

Power and equipment. The plant lost 278 hours to grid outages between January and August. Backup generators were confirmed fully running in September. The company also moved from a leased mining fleet to its own equipment and bought four haul trucks in Q2, which should lower operating costs.

Costs went the wrong way first. Q1 2026 cash cost was $42.55 per AgEq oz. Q2 was $49.28. That’s what a ramp up looks like: you pay for the expansion before you get the tonnes. Q3 and Q4 are where it should start to turn.

One sensitivity is worth keeping in mind. At Q2 grade and recovery, every $10 move in silver is worth about $13.70 a tonne after deductions. At 751 tpd, that’s roughly $10,000 a day, or close to $1 million a quarter. That’s my math and it’s rough, but it shows how much a recovery in silver or a jump in grade would change the picture.

The gold cushion

Something I didn’t expect when I ran these numbers: gold is now carrying more of La Guitarra than silver.

In Q2, gold was about 46% of metal revenue. At today’s prices, it’s about 55%, because silver has fallen about 38% from what Sierra Madre realized in Q2 while gold has fallen about 15%.

For a company most people think of as a silver stock, that’s a real cushion right now. It also means a bad stretch for gold would hurt more than it used to. If you own SM purely as a silver play, it’s worth knowing that at today’s prices it’s closer to a gold and silver play.

The balance sheet and what’s coming due

Sierra Madre ended June with US$22.2 million in cash and US$25 million in working capital. That jumped from US$13.2 million in cash three months earlier, mostly because of a C$57.5 million financing tied to the Del Toro deal. The US$5 million First Majestic loan was paid off by early July, so there’s no financial debt besides leases. About US$5.3 million more came in from warrant exercises after the quarter.

Against that, there’s a lot of planned spending:

  • Del Toro restart: about US$10 million for equipment, plant, lab and contingency, plus about US$5 million for mine development, aiming at a mid 2028 production milestone at 800 tpd, later rising to 1,600.
  • Del Toro exploration: US$12 million over 24 to 30 months, including 30,000 metres of drilling starting mid 2027, with a new resource report targeted for early 2028.
  • Del Toro care and maintenance: about US$1.5 million a year.
  • Deferred acquisition payment: US$10 million due within 18 months of the June close, which can be paid partly in shares, subject to a cap.
  • East District drilling at La Guitarra: 30,000 metres, started in early November.
  • Phase 2 at La Guitarra: 1,200 to 1,500 tpd by Q3 2027, with a second crushing circuit and a permitted 5.8 million tonne dry stack tailings facility. I haven’t seen a capital cost for it.

Add up the Del Toro items alone and it’s roughly US$38 million over the next two years or so, before Phase 2 and before the East District program. Again, my math.

At $47 silver the cash is fine for the near term. But those commitments look a lot easier if La Guitarra is generating real cash than if it’s breaking even. That’s the whole question in one sentence.

The ownership is worth a mention too. As of November 9, institutions held about 42%, strategic holders about 24% with First Majestic the largest disclosed holder, and management and insiders about 5%. Insiders made nine purchases totaling 513,500 shares over the past six months against one sale of 121,000, a net 392,500 shares bought at prices between roughly C$1.30 and C$1.95. That’s not a reason to own the stock. It does tell you the people closest to the operation have been adding at these levels, not leaving.

What two analysts think the mine becomes

The longer term production estimates out there are far apart.

VSA Capital’s Oliver O’Donnell, with a Buy rating and a C$2.70 target, has 2026 at 440,000 oz silver and 4,400 oz gold, rising to more than 1.3 million oz silver and about 12,000 oz gold after Phase 2.

Lepouttre at Caesars Report has eventual output closer to 800,000 oz silver and 12,000 oz gold, about 1.5 million silver equivalent ounces at 60:1, and calls that the lower end of expectations.

Same gold. More than 500,000 oz apart on silver. Both are presumably working from the same mill plan, so the gap is almost entirely grade and recovery assumptions. From 440,000 oz, getting to 800,000 is close to double. Getting to 1.3 million is about triple. At $47 silver, which of those two numbers turns out right matters a lot more than it did at $76.

What to watch

Q3 results, due any day. Silver was a lot higher than today for most of Q3, so the Q3 margin will probably look fine. That’s not the test. What matters in Q3 is cost per tonne against $142.44, head grade against 65 g/t, and silver recovery against 73.6%, because those carry into Q4. Any October or early Q4 production figure in the release would be worth more than the quarter itself.

San Rafael grades. If the higher grade blocks are feeding the mill, it should show up in head grade quickly.

Q4, in February or March. This is where $47 silver actually shows up in the numbers.

The Fed on December 8 to 9, and the dollar. A hike is priced in. The dollar and the 10 year are what silver has been trading on.

The Silver Institute interim review. If it moves its 2026 deficit closer to Metals Focus’s 35.4 million ounces, the deficit story gets weaker. If it holds near 46 million, it pushes back on the solar pessimism.

Funding. If cost per tonne comes down and silver stabilizes, the Del Toro and Phase 2 spending can come mostly from the mine and the treasury. If not, I’d expect Sierra Madre to come back to the market at some point, and at C$1.40 that would be more dilutive than anyone would like.

Where this leaves things

The May thesis leaned on three things: deficits, solar demand, and a falling gold to silver ratio. The first is weaker but still there. The second has turned into a risk. The third reversed. The thing that really drove silver this year, rates and the dollar, wasn’t the focus at all.

Sierra Madre at $47 silver is a bet on two things at once: that silver doesn’t stay here, and that the company gets La Guitarra’s cost per tonne down and grade up fast enough that it doesn’t need to. The first is out of anyone’s control. The second shows up in the numbers over the next two quarters.

I’d rather own a producer that’s improving its operation into a weak price than one coasting on a strong one. But at today’s prices there’s a lot less room for error at La Guitarra than there was in May, and anyone owning SM should be watching Q3 and Q4 for execution, not for the silver price.

Companies in this piece: Sierra Madre Gold and Silver Ltd.

Sources

  1. Yahoo Finance: Silver prices today, November 16, 2026
  2. Goodreturns: Gold and silver rates, November 16, 2026
  3. Kitco: Rate hike bets keep gold on track for its worst week in four months, Nov 13
  4. Kitco: Gold, silver plunge as hotter US inflation raises prospect of larger Fed hike, Nov 10
  5. FXEmpire: Silver miners are getting less from every tonne
  6. FXEmpire: Why the silver price case now rests on investors
  7. IndexBox: BMO on silver and the gold to silver ratio
  8. The Deep Dive: Sierra Madre Q2 2026 results
  9. Caesars Report: La Guitarra tunes up, Del Toro warms up, Sept 14
  10. Sierra Madre: East District drill program, Nov 5
  11. Streetwise Reports (sponsored by Sierra Madre): mill throughput and drill program, Nov 9