Silver, Long Form
Same metal, three price decks: why silver study headlines are hard to compare
Three silver projects in North America, three base case prices from US$31 to US$55. The headline NPV only means something once you know the deck behind it.
November 5, 2026
Economic studies arrive with a big number at the top, usually an after-tax net present value. Read three of them in a row and it is tempting to line those numbers up and rank the projects. With silver moving as much as it has, that is often the wrong way to read them.
Three studies, three prices
Tonopah West in Nevada uses a base case of US$31 per ounce silver and US$2,700 gold. The updated study on the El Tigre Stockwork Zone in Sonora uses US$38 silver and US$3,200 gold. Calico in California, published in October 2026, uses US$55 silver. For context, silver was trading near US$51 at the end of October, about 58% below its January record.
Those are not small gaps. The highest silver price here is about 77% above the lowest. Each study reflects when it was written and what its authors chose as a reasonable base case, so a higher NPV on a higher deck does not tell you which project is stronger.
| Project | Base case silver | After-tax NPV (5%) | After-tax IRR |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tonopah West | US$31 | US$437M | 28% |
| El Tigre Stockwork Zone | US$38 | US$456M | 65.7% |
| Calico | US$55 | US$737M | 25% |
The same project at two prices
El Tigre shows the effect well, because it has been studied more than once. The 2024 prefeasibility study showed an after-tax NPV of US$222 million at US$26 silver and US$2,150 gold. The 2026 update showed US$456 million at US$38 silver and US$3,200 gold, with the same 10-year mine life.
Costs and plans can change between studies too, so price is not the only difference. Even so, it is a useful reminder of how much of a headline can come from the deck.
What to compare instead
Start with the study level. A prefeasibility study carries more engineering than a preliminary economic assessment, and a preliminary economic assessment can include inferred resources, which are the least certain category.
Then look at scale and capital. Initial capital ranges from US$86.8 million in El Tigre’s 2026 study, since revised to a US$124 million budget, to US$190.4 million at Tonopah West and US$633 million at Calico. Those are very different projects to finance, whatever the NPV says.
Finally, look at timing. El Tigre’s Stockwork Zone is under construction, while the other two are still working through studies and permitting. A dollar of value that arrives in two years is not the same as one that arrives in eight.
A simple habit
Before you repeat any NPV, write down the metal price behind it, the study level and the initial capital. If those three things do not line up across projects, the comparison is not telling you what it appears to.
Companies in this piece: Blackrock Silver Corp., Silver Tiger Metals Inc., Apollo Silver Corp.